Pizza restaurants

SLOPPY JOE'S PIZZA

4.8 135 reviews 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM 54 New Hartford Shopping Center, New Hartford, NY 13413, United States

Discover this place

Sloppy Joe's Pizza, located in New Hartford, NY, has quickly made a name for itself among local pizza lovers. Customers rave about the consistent quality and freshness of the food, making it a go-to spot for both dine-in and delivery. Christian Conner's spontaneous visit resulted in a delightful dining experience, underscoring the restaurant's ability to impress even at a moment's notice.

However, the standout dish seems to be their calzones, especially the spinach calzone, which some have found to be on the smaller side. Theresa Marie had mixed feelings, noting its incredible flavor but lamenting its size compared to traditional calzones. For those who prefer heartier options, the mac & cheese, cheeseburger deluxe, and upside down pizza are frequently highlighted as must-tries.

With its clean setting and friendly service, Sloppy Joe's Pizza ensures that every order arrives piping hot and exactly as requested. As noted by customers like Chastity Ballard and Katrina Briody, the passion the owner displays is palpable. In a bustling pizza market, this restaurant stands out for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. If you're seeking remarkable pizza in New Hartford, look no further than Sloppy Joe's Pizza!

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with SLOPPY JOE'S PIZZA before visiting.

Reviews for SLOPPY JOE'S PIZZA

4.8

135 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 135 reviews

SLOPPY JOE'S PIZZA in New Hartford is consistently praised for its fresh, hot, and flavorful food, earning a strong reputation for quality across its menu. Customers frequently highlight the friendly and attentive service, contributing to a welcoming, clean atmosphere despite the restaurant's relatively small size. While portion sizes, particularly for items like the calzone, have drawn some remarks about being smaller than expected, the overall taste and preparation remain well-regarded. Delivery services are described as prompt, maintaining the freshness and quality of the meals. The combination of excellent food, personable staff, and reliable service positions SLOPPY JOE'S as a favored local spot for pizza lovers seeking a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.

Christian Conner

Jun 08, 2025

We went here for dinner, and the food is so good. This was a list minute decision and I am happy we stopped in. I'm very surprised they are not busier. Food was perfectly cooked.

Theresa marie

May 04, 2025

12/18/24 delivery via grubhub was prompt. I debated deducting a star, but the calazone itself was delicious, despite it's rather tiny & small size.... I'm just in shock at how small it was. It was comparable to an empanada!!!! Ordered a spinach calazone. Received fresh & hot. it was delicious like most everything I've ordered from here. But I must say for the price, this was the tiniest calazone I've ever seen from any place ever! Most calazone are two to three times bigger. It was just a tad shorter than the length of my butter knife & about 3 inches in width. See pics. I would never order another calazone for the price i paid, just get a small pizza, lol. Unbelievable I've ordered weekly from sloppy joes for past few months. Everything has been as requested, My favorites that I usually order are the mac & cheese ( so good & creamy), cheeseburger deluxe ( delicious) , upside down pizza ( love it), BLT ( bacon crispy, awesome sandwich) Everything has been delivered very hot & freshly cooked. Special requests are honored for additional cost. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Zhiel Obrien

Apr 05, 2025

Small but clean restaurant. Friendly guy serving good food ....will be back again ....highly recommended

Chastity Ballard

Apr 05, 2025

Amazing owner and the food always tastes fresh, hot & amazing!! Highly recommended!!!

Katrina Briody

Mar 28, 2025

Greatest pizza around and impeccable service!! If you’re going to get pizza, get it here!

Dayyayo

Mar 28, 2025

Love finding good lunch spots! I got a large Buffalo Chicken sub, all ingredients were fresh & the meal was neatly packed, ready to go when I arrived. I'll be back

Eddie Supley

Mar 25, 2025

Great food, atmosphere and customer service!! Glad we checked it out and definitely coming back whenever in the area!

Dylan Shepard

Mar 05, 2025

If I’m eating pizza Tuesday-Saturday the only pizza place in my mind is Sloppy Joes. Impeccable pizza, and a great family business. Upon entering the door there is immediately friendly and genuine conversation. They have unique pizza that you can’t get anywhere else around here, like their delicious chicken speedie pizza. My only suggestion for change is 24/7 service.